Just going to start off saying that the User profile page is still undergoing a lot of work. The main point of the image-based one that you hate is to show off those uploaded avatars. There's a lot of issues with that display currently, but it's not going away.
Let me address your Character page points though:
- The HUGE picture (where the "old" page had the character summary): EEEEWWW!
CIT had even bigger pictures there if you put them there, at least in terms of height. It's one of my favorite parts and it's definitely staying... sorry.
The Low-Hanging Fruit, Missing, and Unverified lists I believe should be a part of the manage sections, not the public profile - and that's where they'll end up when re-introduced.
Individual progress bars will probably make a return soon.
CoHPlanner is all manner of screwed up, and until I get the chance to sort those issues, the build section will be on vacation. Once I give the Planner some love, with any luck the integration will be a LOT smoother.
I mean other than those things, the profile has all the data that was on the CIT profile page.
I'm sorry you're not a fan of the new character page, but I have to say that overall I'm pretty happy with the way it looks. Will there be tweaks? I'm 100% sure of it... but in general I think it's pretty solid.